2023 Honda HR-V vs. CR-V: Comfort-Seeking Compact SUV Buyers

The Honda HR-V and CR-V have long been popular and reliable options for small crossovers, but many buyers become confused when trying to determine which model best suits their needs. This comprehensive comparison examines the key differences between the 2023 Honda HR-V and 2023 CR-V across critical categories - outlining strengths, weaknesses, and ideal buyers for each compact SUV.

Safety and Reliability: CR-V Pulls Ahead

When purchasing a new vehicle, safety and reliability should be top priorities - after all, protecting lives and avoiding breakdowns qualify firmly within the YMYL (Your Money or Your Life) concept. Here, the CR-V gains a decisive advantage with its more robust selection of standard and available driver assistance technology.

The IIHS awarded the 2023 CR-V its top score of “Good” in all crash tests, plus superior ratings for crash prevention systems. The 2023 HR-V has not yet been tested. However, based on the updated HR-V’s advanced new platform and similarity to other high-scoring Hondas, comparable results can reasonably be expected.

In terms of predicted long-term reliability, J.D Power scores the CR-V better than average at 83/100 - higher than the HR-V’s still-decent 75/100 score. Both models offer strong powertrain warranties of up to 5 years/60,000 miles.

Model	Safety Tech	Crash Scores	Reliability	Warranty
2023 Honda CR-V	More standard equipment like adaptive cruise control; and available blind spot monitoring	Top "Good" scores in all IIHS tests (predicted for 2023 HR-V)	Above average - 83/100	5 years / 60,000 miles
2023 Honda HR-V	Less standard tech like lane keep assist only; no availability upgrades	Not yet tested, but expected "Good" based on the platform	Average - 75/100	5 years / 60,000 miles

For shoppers wanting maximum peace of mind - especially families with younger drivers - the CR-V delivers superior crash protection and confidence in avoiding repairs. Still, the HR-V promises baseline Honda quality and safety seen across models.

Performance and MPG: A Question of Power

The 2023 Honda CR-V offers buyers a choice of efficient powertrains: an adequate 1.5-liter turbo 4-cylinder, a fuel-sipping hybrid variant, or a punchier turbo 2.0-liter upgrade in top trims. Output ranges from 190 horsepower up to a robust 222 ponies.

By contrast, the sole HR-V engine option feels nearly anemic. Its naturally aspirated 2.0-liter 4-cylinder pushes out a modest 158 horsepower and 139 lb-ft torque. Acceleration suffers at higher speeds, especially with passengers or cargo loaded.

More disappointingly, the CR-V still delivers superior efficiency over the HR-V:

Model	City MPG	Highway MPG	Available AWD?
2023 Honda CR-V	28-40 mpg	34-35 mpg	Yes
2023 Honda HR-V	26-28 mpg	31-34 mpg	Yes

Clearly for driving enthusiasts - or hauling trailers small and large - the CR-V’s stronger engine and hybrid options make an attractive choice. Yet city commuters may largely be satisfied by the adequate if sluggish powertrain of an HR-V.

Cabin Space and Cargo: A Roominess and Storage Comparison

On paper, the interior dimensions of the CR-V and HR-V seem similar. But experiences behind the wheel tell a very different story of true spaciousness, especially the farther back you sit.

Thanks to a nearly 5-inch longer wheelbase and extra width, the CR-V provides adults notably better comfort in its rear seats and cargo area. For families or rideshare duty, the superior rear legroom, headroom and hip space of the CR-V make it a more livable compact crossover every day.

Cargo room and versatility also set the CR-V ahead:

Spec	2023 Honda CR-V	2023 Honda HR-V
Front Headroom	39.1 inches	39.4 inches
Front Legroom	41.3 inches	41.9 inches
Rear Headroom	39.5 inches	38 inches
Rear Legroom	40.4 inches	36.7 inches
Passenger Volume	103.7 cubic feet	98.7 cubic feet
Rear Cargo Room	75.8 cubic feet (seats down)	24.4 cubic feet

Biblically speaking, “The last shall be first”—and that's often how rear passengers feel in the back of an HR-V. Unless frequently traveling with kids or small adults only, most customers need to seriously consider the superior practicality of the CR-V for robust family duty or road trips.

Styling and Tech: A Matter of Taste

Beauty remains firmly in the eye of the beholder when judging either CR-V or HR-V on aesthetics. For customers seeking something sportier and more playful, the HR-V’s newly aggressive lines, polygon motif mesh grille, and handling-focused Sport Touring trim will appeal strongly.

In contrast, the CR-V adopts more mainstream, upscale styling with a sense of polished refinement. Its bolder chrome grille mesh and range of trim options allow more customization based on preferences.

In cabins, both models offer excellent top-down visibility, with the HR-V feeling more airy thanks to its full panoramic moonroof. Large touchscreens house intuitive infotainment systems - though the HR-V’s standard 7-inch display looks somewhat dated next to the bold, frameless 9-inch screen found even on base CR-V LX models. A full digital gauge cluster further elevates higher CR-V trims.

Overall, those less concerned with keeping up with Joneses will find strong appeal in the youthful looks of the HR-V. But the CR-V brings greater choices in its distinguished style backed by luxury options - albeit sometimes feeling like ubiquitous "vanilla" amid parking lots.

Cost and Value Comparison: HR-V Holds Strong Appeal

Finally, the scales tip back towards parity when examining MSRP and overall value between these two fine Hondas. Due to its larger size and extra equipment, the CR-V does demand a nearly $4,300 premium over base HR-V LX models. However, higher trims align more closely as advanced features balance added scale:

Model	Starting MSRP	Top Trim MSRP
2023 Honda HR-V	$25,395	EX-L - $30,195
2023 Honda CR-V	$29,695	Touring - $37,755

With today's budget-minded buyers, value plays an essential role when evaluating vehicle purchases against household needs. Here the HR-V makes a compelling case to frugal shoppers - offering Honda goodness in a pint-sized package for those less concerned with space limitations or towing needs.

Recommending the Best 2023 Honda Compact Crossover

Ultimately when comparing the new 2023 Honda HR-V versus the 2023 CR-V, buyers must carefully weigh priorities around roominess, performance, safety needs, and sticker prices.

• Young urban commuters will likely favor the HOV lane-friendly HR-V for its nimble driving dynamics and lower cost of entry.
• Growing or outdoor-oriented families require the extra practicality of a CR-V for its versatility, with excellent hybrid fuel economies to offset higher monthly payments.

In vehicles as in life, one size rarely fits all customers alike. But with either the 2023 HR-V or CR-V, shoppers find Honda's proven reputation for quality, reliability and retaining the highest resale values - delivering years of happiness on roads ahead.